What is Israel’s medium-term plan (what will end up happening?)?
➕
Plus
35
Ṁ3154
Dec 23
8%
Kill some Hamas leaders, then get out
5%
Install a puppet government
76%
Permanently occupy Gaza like they’re occupying the West Bank
0.8%
Get bogged down in a stalemate
5%
Permanently cut gaza in half, occupy the North
4%
Other

Inspired by Scott:

https://www.astralcodexten.com/p/mantic-monday-103023

"I can’t find any markets on the Middle East topic I’m actually interested in, which is Israel’s medium-term plan. Will they kill some Hamas leaders, then get out? Install a puppet government? Permanently occupy Gaza like they’re occupying the West Bank? These all seem like bad options, but they’re very different bad options, and I haven’t seen much speculation about which is most likely."

Close date may be extended if it seems like the situation hasn't settled down.

  • Update 2024-10-12 (PST): The market will resolve as 'Permanently occupy Gaza like they're occupying the West Bank' unless the creator is convinced otherwise. (AI summary of creator comment)

Get
Ṁ1,000
and
S3.00
Sort by:

If I see Scott at Solstice, I'll try to seek clarification. Otherwise I'll just go ahead and resolve anyway

I intend to resolve "Permanently occupy Gaza like they’re occupying the West Bank" unless convinced otherwise

I don't understand why Israel getting out is still trading so high

"Permanently occupy" and "Install a puppet government" aren't mutually exclusive? How does this resolve if there's a puppet government with an occupation propping it up?

@UnspecifiedPerson looks like it can be resolved to multiple answers

Any sign of Israel leaving anytime soon?

"the Gaza story is over. The Israelis won’t leave it to Hamas ever again. They learned this lesson on October 7. From now on they will keep close tabs on it and will remain boots on the ground indefinitely."

opened a Ṁ100 YES at 45% order

I think July is a bit too early to resolve this.

@Daniel_MC I know I said close may be extended, but I don't want to keep extending it indefinitely, because it is medium term, not long term.

How do you plan to handle claims that the plan was A bit unexpected events led to B? Would you rely on claims about the initial plan from Israeli officials? Expert analysis?

@0482 I'll go with what actually ends up happening.

Does that option imply Hamas is still in charge and remain significant military capabilities?

The analogy to the West Bank means there must be civilian settlements for this to be resolved as YES? Otherwise it's more like the historic South Lebanon situation

Passing control to the Palestinian National Authority - is it "puppet government" or "other"?

I think this will be really tough to resolve and I will not invest more than a little gambling money here.

Here is my try:
/marketwise/will-israel-occupy-gaza-in-april
/marketwise/will-israel-withdraw-again-from-gaz

© Manifold Markets, Inc.Terms + Mana-only TermsPrivacyRules